Newcastle's forward play produced repeated box entries in the derby, while Macarthur's first league win came from a much thinner supply of ordinary-play chances. The Bulls can break quickly through the middle and have useful delivery from Fraser. This match should turn on whether Newcastle's wide service reaches a second receiver before Macarthur's screen settles.
Lolley made six key passes against Central Coast, and Wood scored from a move that used Shaughnessy's header back across the box. Wood also missed two big chances, so the volume of entries matters more than that derby score alone. Macarthur allowed Perth six efforts on target, while its own nine shots included only two on target; its comeback needed a retaken penalty and a Fraser free kick. Rose and Randazzo can protect the centre, with Gibson and Vickery ready to run into space after a regain.
Grant's place in Newcastle's extended squad follows two unused substitute appearances, so his effect on the back line is still an open selection detail. Cooper and Fryer were already missing in the derby, while Toure played only as a substitute for Macarthur before a reported shoulder problem; Fraser's delivery was evident in his 35 minutes. Newcastle can build through Lolley and Wood early and keep finding the box later. That's why I'm siding with Newcastle to finish the stronger attacking sequence with a win.